Signing Mike Napoli was a winning move for the Red Sox

On this date in 2003, the Red Sox made one of the best free-agent signings of all time. The story of David Ortiz’s Red Sox career is well-known and often recounted. So let’s fast-forward to this date eight years ago when the Red Sox added another pretty good first baseman/designated hitter: Mike Napoli put pen to paper and officially signed a one-year deal worth $5 million guaranteed. The deal was notable because the two sides had previously agreed to a three-year, $39 million contract that fell apart because of concern over the health of Napoli’s hip.

After the failed physical, Napoli briefly flirted with a return to the Texas Rangers, with whom he’d spent the previous two seasons. Napoli had been a significant trade acquisition for Texas following the 2010 season, making his one and only All-Star team while helping the Rangers repeat as American League champions. Even though Texas would fall for the second consecutive season in the World Series, Napoli played lights out, slashing .350/.464/.700 in 28 plate appearances with two home runs and 10 RBI.

Regardless, the Red Sox had more at-bats to offer the former catcher, and he became Boston’s new first baseman with a deal guaranteeing $5 million while still providing a ceiling of $13 million based on incentives. The 31-year-old would take home the full boat, cashing in with 139 games played, 578 plate appearances, and 3.7 rWAR by way of a .259/.360/.482 batting line. He chipped in 23 home runs despite a 32.4 percent strikeout rate.

Napoli was absolutely a contributing factor in the Red Sox turning around a 93-loss team from the previous season, becoming a 97-win juggernaut that rolled past the Rays, Tigers and Cardinals to win the World Series. Even though Napoli would play in the World Series three times, 2013 was the only time he’d walk away with a ring.

Ultimately, even though the hip issue got Napoli’s Boston tenure off to an inauspicious start, the relationship was an unmitigated success, so much so that Napoli re-upped following that 2013 campaign for another two seasons at an average annual value of $16 million. Ultimately, Napoli earned $45 million over that three-year stretch, well more than the $39 million he would have earned under the original terms of his deal.

These days, Napoli is a Quality Assurance Coach on the staff of one of his former teammates from that 2013 team, David Ross.